Insights of Change
  • Insights
  • Music & Lyrics
  • Library
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5

psychotherapy and change

3/3/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
A Safe Place For Change by Hugh Crago and Penny Gardner. The following review is by Elizabeth Day PhD.
" My engagement with this text, as with most texts, commenced from the back. I felt reassured to find in the index trusted thinkers such as Foucault and Rorty, and systems for working with the ‘self’ experience such as Buddhism, along with current and classic thinker-practitioners: Alice Miller, Irvin Yalom, Karen Horney, Babette Rothschild; also Ainsworth, Berg, Rogers, Wilber, White. This, I inferred, was a text that pays its dues. I was mildly disappointed, however, to find no Husserl, Heidegger, or Merleau-Ponty. This omission is not unusual in counselling and therapy texts, though (of which more, later). I enjoyed the implicit irony in index entries such as ‘complainants, see client’ and ‘there and then, see here and now’. And the fact that there were many more references in the index to ‘silence’ than to ‘minimal encouragers’ satisfied me that this was not merely a how-to guide, but a text grounded in its disciplinary roots.​
The authors declare this a text intended for first-year counselling and therapy trainees. The title signifies its emphasis (safety) on the training and therapeutic relationship, and the topic sequence takes students through the development of a holding capacity, to exploring (deepening) issues, using techniques (fix v re-parent), challenging the client, coaching, and ending.
The authors have avoided a focus on ‘model-specific skills’, opting instead for common competencies for the ‘competent helper’. They locate their work within the complex matrix of therapeutic orientations and techniques, with interpersonal awareness at the core, and work within the parameters they establish to create a developmental training model.
Right up front the text challenges the trainee to direct the enquiry inward (Ch 1: ‘So you want to help people?’), cautioning that ‘You can’t take a client where you haven’t been yourself (p 5), and it places a research-based and experience-based emphasis on the development of capacities of presence and holding (Ch 2 ‘being there: developing the capacity for holding’) as the ground for effective therapeutic work.
Rather more interpersonal than instrumentalist, the text provides a model of change based, refreshingly, on the therapist’s capacity for being rather than doing (p 10). Here we could add the importance of the client’s capacity for the same, per Beisser’s (1970) paradox: change becomes more possible when first we become how and what we are (in all its perceived unloveliness) before stepping in to how and what we want to be.
The authors make no claim to be exhaustive; rather, they situate their arguments within a broader field of research and enjoin readers to learn more about a given area, through the device of breakout boxes – ‘Read more’ and ‘Think about it’ – positioned at strategic points in the chapters.
The text progresses its argument through sometimes exquisite examples of client-therapist dialogue, exemplifying right at the point where a student may be struggling to imagine the abstract notions into applied practice. It directly addresses its reader. This is sometimes conversational: ‘at this point, some of you are probably wondering … and that’s a fair comment’ (p 153), sometimes presumptuously: ‘Relax! You’re not expected to perceive such deep-level connections…not at this stage, anyway’. In all these ways it engages readers in the learning process.
I enjoyed the confident challenges to industry assumptions around advice-giving (there’s a time and place), use of I-statements (over-emphasis on this can irritate clients, and miss the point), closed and ‘why’ questions (there’s a time and place); and a refusal to be prescriptive or to labour through the various micro-skills as though they were the alpha and the omega of therapy.
The text’s historical-consciousness around key terms is of great use to first-year students who generally struggle to make sense of the differences between counselling and psychotherapy, psychotherapy and psychology, patients and clients. Counselling and psychotherapy are here distinguished by their orientations: counselling is defined as a content orientated ‘problem-focused approach’ and psychotherapy as a process orientated ‘relational approach’, with allowance that each can include aspects of the other.
Impressed that on the very first page the authors invite critical engagement with the text – ‘We welcome questioning of the positions we have taken here’ – and in the spirit of that invitation, I make the following comments on two matters – the helper model, and the philosophical heart of therapy.

Helper
I cannot get comfortable with the ‘helper’ orientation, so usefully problematised in the first chapter but deployed throughout. The designation of therapy as a ‘helping’ profession became ingrained perhaps from the widespread adoption of Egan’s ‘Skilled Helper’ model. I find the notion reduces the therapeutic orientation to some kind of first aid, and is implicitly problem-oriented. While that may be the case sometimes, I see the therapeutic role pertaining more to an orientation of enquiry. Donna Orange’s (2012) recent coinage ‘clinical hospitality’ may yet get definitional traction in the field, though its evocation of the clinic and the hospital is still far from the philosophical roots of her own training. This relates to my next point.

Philosophy
The authors state up front that their concern is with the practical component of counsellor training, based on their perception that students ‘overwhelmingly prefer textbooks that are clear and direct in their language’, and that acknowledge difficulties faced by beginners (p vii).
Inevitably such choices have to be considered when writing texts for disciplines that blend theory with application. And inevitably one choice excludes others. At a time (now) and place (Australia) where the empirical end of the research spectrum is the current locus for what passes as evidence-based research, there is a heightened need for counselling and therapy to emerge as a discipline distinct from the science-derived systems of psychology.
Far from being the disdained bastard child of a medical model, counselling and therapy at least in their humanistic, postmodern, intersubjective incarnations, are twin inheritors of a venerable philosophical lineage: Husserl, Heidegger, Merleau-Ponty, and its offshoots of literary, sociological and poststructural theories of self, and of discourse. Moreover the bedrock practices of presence and awareness pre-date Husserl and trace back through centuries of phenomenological enquiry. I consider it a great asset for students to be introduced to the deep intellectual and ontological roots that inform the relational and change elements of their practice. And I am confident that this can be done without frightening the horses.
In an endnote to Chapter 5 we get:  
‘Indeed it may be that all therapeutic models converge on core principles that are indistinguishable from those acknowledged within most major spiritual traditions…what …Wilber calls the ‘perennial philosophy”
(p 228).  I appreciated this and would have welcomed a chapter on it.
In the broader context of the endeavor of this text, however, and the training model it presents, my comments here are offered as engagements with its thinking mind, rather than contradictions of those choices. I would recommend the text to first-year students as a sound companion to learning how the art of therapy starts with self enquiry. "
Dr Elizabeth Day  is a contributing member of the Psychotherapy and Counselling Journal of Australia 
A Safe Place For Change is available in paperback from Amazon.com $299.00 (27/02/2016)

References
Beisser, A. (1970). The Paradoxical Theory of Change, in J. Fagan & I. Shepherd, eds. (1970/1971), Gestalt Therapy Now, 
New York, Harper.
Orange, D. (2012). The Suffering Stranger: Hermeneutics for Everyday Clinical Practice. New York: Routledge.
​
#psychotherapy  #counselling

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    to Open Library
    to Project Gutenberg
    Tweets about #change

    Info

    All
    101 Ideas That Changed The Way We Think
    Adam Cash
    Albert Ellis
    Anthony Scioli And Henry B. Biller
    A Safe Place For Change
    Behaviourism
    Burt Goldman
    Can A Book Change Your Life?
    Can't Afford The Luxury Of A Negative Thought
    Career Change
    Change Anything
    Change Habits
    Change Video Message From Kevin
    Change Your Attitude Change Your Life Videos
    Change Your Beliefs Video
    Change Your Life
    Change Your Man Change Your Life Review
    Changing For Good
    Changing Minds
    Changing Your Career
    Charles Duhigg
    Christopher Lanne
    Constantine Andriopoulos
    Coping With Changing Schools
    Diclemente
    Dr Micheal J Mahoney
    Eat Right For Your Type
    Empowerment
    Empowerment Supports Change
    Florence Scovel
    Flourishing In Change
    Gastroenterology
    Giulia Enders
    Give Your Speech Video Review
    Highly Sensitive Persons Survival Guide Video Review
    Hormonal Change
    Howard Gardner
    Hugh Crago & Penny Gardner
    Human Change Processes
    Jennifer O'Connell
    Jill Bolte Taylor
    Jim Butcher
    Joann Davis
    Kaedrich Olsen
    Katherine Woodward Thomas
    Kenya K Stephens
    Kerry Patterson Et Al
    Kevin Montgomery
    Kevin Nalts
    Libby Rees
    Life Changing
    Lion Goodman
    Managing Change
    Mark Roeder
    Martin Seligman
    Mind Change
    Moeletsi Mbeki
    My Orange Duffel Bag Review Video
    My Stroke Of Insight
    Neurological Change
    Nick Morgan
    Norcross
    Norman Doidge
    Patrick Dawson
    Paul Gilbert
    Portia De Rossi
    Power To Change Your Life Video
    Prochaska
    Psychology For Dummies Video Review
    Psychotherapy
    Quantum Jumping Video Review
    Quantum Worth Review
    Richard J. Davidson
    Robbins & Finley
    Robert Ed Arp
    Roger And Mcwilliams
    Runes For Transformation
    Sharon Fried Buchalter
    Susan Greenfield
    Ted Zeff
    The Compassionate Mind
    The Emotional Life Of Your Brain
    The Little Secret That Can Change Your Life
    The Myth Of Self Esteem
    The Power Of Hope
    Tim Rayner
    Unbearable Lightness Book Review
    What You Can Change And What You Can't
    Why Change Doesn't Work

    Archive

    October 2018
    July 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    March 2016
    December 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    May 2014
    February 2014
    September 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    October 2011
    September 2011
    July 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011

    Picture
     b/bear change project  

    Picture
    The Change Blog
    Laws of Changing Thought
    File Size: 1407 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Change Your Language
    File Size: 131 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Change Your Depression
    File Size: 81 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Change your Thinking
    File Size: 2442 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Changing Negative Thoughts
    File Size: 129 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Picture
    What people say is often very different to what
    ​they think or feel ~ Allan & Barbara Pease
    ​

    body_language.pdf
    File Size: 2846 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Picture
    One Belief Worksheet
    File Size: 112 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    Worksheet Emotions List
    File Size: 93 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File


Blessed are they who have learned to bear what they cannot change.
For every ailment under the sun, there is a remedy, or there is none.
If there be one, try to find it, If there be none, never mind it.


2011 - 2021
chan6es.com